If you’re weighing up coffee claims, chain of custody coffee models are the rules behind them. Four main models exist, from identity preserved to book-and-claim, and they differ in how much physical mixing they allow.
This guide is one part of the wider topic of coffee traceability.
| Item | Value |
|---|---|
| Models in the UN Transparency Protocol 0.6.0 categorisation | 4 (identity preserved, segregated, mass balance, book-and-claim) |
| Organic share of input wheat in the mass balance example | 40% |
| Conventional share of input wheat in the same example | 60% |
| Most flour that example mill can sell as organic from 100 tons of wheat | 40 tons |
| Price paid in a Kenya coffee example from a 2022 blog post | 149% above the fair trade price |
The figures come from the UN Transparency Protocol chain of custody page and a Circularise blog post. Figures and specifications can change, so check the source before you rely on them.
What chain of custody means for coffee
A chain of custody is the process of following materials through every step of the supply chain, from sourcing and production to processing, shipping and retail, according to a Circularise blog post dated November 17, 2022. It relies on procedures, technologies and documents that link a material to its end product.
For coffee, the practical question is what a label such as “single-origin” or “certified” lets a buyer conclude about the bag in their hands. A chain of custody model sets out how certified and non-certified coffee may be handled, and therefore which claim can be made.
The UN Transparency Protocol (UNTP) describes four models, and says each balances operational practicality and assurance in a different way. You can read the UNTP chain of custody page for the full wording. The four are:
- Identity preserved: the certified source stays unchanged and unblended.
- Segregated: certified material is kept apart from non-certified material.
- Mass balance: mixing is allowed, but claims are capped by the qualifying input.
- Book-and-claim: the claim is separated from the physical goods.
Identity preserved and segregated: no mixing with non-qualifying coffee
Under identity preserved, the exact certified source of the product remains unchanged and unblended throughout the supply chain, as the UNTP page puts it. Its own coffee example is a bag that stays separate from other coffee beans, whether qualifying or not, throughout processing and transport.
The benefit is the strongest assurance and a direct link back to a specific farm. The cost is that the same page calls it among the most costly and complex approaches, because every stage needs identification and segregation.
The Circularise post says the specialty coffee industry has thrived and benefited greatly from adopting this model. It cites This Side Up Coffees as an example, describing a partnership with a women’s collective in Kenya and a price of 149% above the fair trade price. That is the post’s own description, and this page has not checked it independently.
The segregated model also keeps qualifying and non-qualifying quantities apart. The difference, per the UNTP page, is that qualifying quantities from different certified sources meeting the same standard may be combined.
The final product is still entirely qualifying, but it is not guaranteed to come from a single farm. Keeping material physically separate can still raise logistics and storage costs.
Mass balance and book-and-claim: decoupling claims from the physical product
In mass balance, controlled mixing of qualifying and non-qualifying quantities is allowed, as long as the volume of qualifying outputs does not exceed the volume of qualifying inputs. The UNTP page illustrates this with a flour mill that receives certified organic wheat (40%) and conventional wheat (60%).
If that mill processes 100 tons in total, it can sell up to 40 tons of flour as organic, whichever grains ended up in which sack. The page gives no coffee example for this model, but the same input-versus-output arithmetic would apply to any commodity.
The page lists reasons a business might choose it:
- Facilities may be unable to keep products separate during transport or storage.
- Minimum production quantities may not be met by qualifying material alone.
- Separation costs can make certified material uncompetitive on price.
The trade-off is dilution. Buyers cannot be certain their specific product contains qualifying material, only that an equivalent volume of qualifying material was used elsewhere in the process.
In book-and-claim, sustainability attributes are decoupled from the physical flow of goods. A producer issues credits into a registry, and a buyer can claim them even when the physical product received is not the certified batch.
The UNTP page says this offers smallholder farmers and small enterprises a way to take part without their local mills or aggregators adopting traceability practices. It also says a trusted registry is essential so that credits are not double-counted or over-issued.
How do the models compare?
| Model | Mixing with non-qualifying goods | Link to a single farm | Main trade-off |
|---|---|---|---|
| Identity preserved | Not allowed | Direct link to a specific origin | Most costly and complex |
| Segregated | Not allowed | Not guaranteed, certified sources may be pooled | Physical separation adds logistics and storage costs |
| Mass balance | Controlled mixing allowed | No, only an equivalent volume is accounted for | Dilution at the physical level |
| Book-and-claim | Claim is decoupled from the goods | No, credits are traded separately | Needs a trusted registry |
The Circularise post suggests identity preserved and segregated models for materials that could come from conflict zones or places where human rights abuse is common. It says mass balance and book-and-claim can be almost entirely decoupled from physical flows, which suits chemical production and green energy.
Standards bodies use the same vocabulary. The contents page of ISO 22095:2020, titled “Chain of custody – General terminology and models”, lists identity preserved, segregated, controlled blending, mass balance and book-and-claim.
The same contents list names two mass balance implementation methods, a rolling average percentage method and a credit method.

Fraud risk and the role of records
The UNTP page calls mass balance fraud a particularly challenging greenwashing vector. It happens when a small quantity of high-integrity input is mixed with lower-quality alternatives and the full volume is sold as sustainable, reusing the valid credentials.
Its proposed fix, described in the UNTP design pattern, uses trusted third parties as quota managers. They issue a guarantee of origin only against evidence of enough sustainable input, and mark that input as consumed so it cannot be presented again to a different third party.
That page is the 0.6.0 version, which is marked as unmaintained and as suitable for pre-production pilot implementations, so treat the details as a snapshot rather than settled practice.
For the wider idea behind these records, what is supply chain transparency is a useful starting point. A companion piece, digital product passport explained, looks at product-level data records.
Frequently asked questions
What is chain of custody in coffee?
Show answer
It is the process of following coffee through sourcing, production, processing, shipping and retail, using procedures and documents that link the finished product to its source. The model chosen decides what claim can be made about it.
Which model gives the strongest traceability?
Show answer
According to the UNTP page, identity preserved achieves the maximum traceability and the strongest assurance, with a direct link to a specific farm or origin. It is also among the most costly and complex to run.
Is mass balance coffee physically the certified coffee?
Show answer
Not necessarily. Dilution occurs at the physical level, so a buyer can only be sure that an equivalent volume of qualifying material was used elsewhere in the process.
Why would a business choose book-and-claim?
Show answer
The UNTP page says it simplifies sustainable sourcing where full traceability across all actors is prohibitively expensive, and lets smallholders take part without their local buyers changing practices. It depends on a trusted registry to prevent double-counting.



